Skip to content
The Journey

Moment

Choice or Disease?

J.S. Ashworth1 min read

A worn wooden kitchen table in warm evening light, with two coffee mugs set across from each other and a candle glowing in the background.

I recently watched the Netflix documentary about Matthew Perry and revisited his debate with Peter Hitchens about addiction.

Was it a choice or a disease?

I’ve spent over four years living with addiction in my family, and I think it’s both.

At some point, there’s often a decision. A choice to try something. But what starts as a choice can become a disease that takes hold of someone’s life.

And not everyone who makes that choice becomes addicted.

So perhaps we’re arguing about the wrong thing.

Why did they make that first decision?

Was it curiosity? Pleasure? Pain? Loneliness? Or simply wanting to feel something different?

I don’t know.

And I don’t believe there’s one answer that applies to everyone.

I believe in personal responsibility. But I also believe in compassion. The two aren’t mutually exclusive.

What struck me most in the documentary was Matthew Perry’s sister speaking about the grief that families experience. The kind of grief that parents, siblings, and others who love someone struggling with addiction carry, often long before anyone dies.

I know something about that grief.

It’s why my book opens with these words:

“The phone rang. I held my breath. I could feel my heart racing. Was this a good call or a bad one? Chances were it wasn’t good. I just hoped to hell that it wasn’t the one I feared the most.”

I’ve learned the importance of staying with the moment. Not trying to control tomorrow, not losing myself in what might happen, but being present for the people I love and for my own life.

Matthew Perry had fame, money, access to treatment, and people who loved him.

Unfortunately, he still died.

Before we judge someone struggling with addiction, perhaps we should spend less time arguing about whether they chose it and more time trying to understand why.

Because understanding someone doesn’t mean excusing them.

Stay with the Moment. Let tomorrow arrive.

If this story speaks to you, feel free to share it.

Did This Moment Speak to You?

Sometimes a story brings up a thought, a memory, or an experience of our own. If you’d like to share yours, I’d welcome hearing from you.

Your message is private and will not be published.

Share your thoughts

Stay Connected

The Journey Continues.

Life continues, bringing new moments, challenges, and unexpected lessons. I’ll share some of those moments here—the experiences, reflections, and everyday stories that remind us we’re all still learning.

If you’d like to follow along, you’re welcome here.

Optional Moments subscription

Only the updates you choose. Unsubscribe anytime. See privacy.